The Beautiful Game

Recently Updated

The Beautiful Game: A Musical of Resilience on the West End

The Beautiful Game, a musical with music by Andrew Lloyd Webber and book and lyrics by Ben Elton, premiered at London’s Cambridge Theatre in the West End on September 26, 2000. Directed by Robert Carsen, this ambitious work ran for 391 performances, closing on September 1, 2001. Set against the backdrop of Northern Ireland’s Troubles in 1969, it follows a group of Belfast teenagers whose dreams of football stardom and love collide with sectarian violence. Starring Josie Walker and David Shannon, the show won the 2000 Critics’ Circle Award for Best Musical, blending a Celtic-tinged score with a gritty narrative. Though it struggled commercially, its legacy lives on through revisions and a passionate cult following.

Origins and West End Debut

The Beautiful Game emerged from an unlikely pairing: Lloyd Webber, seeking a fresh collaborator, approached Elton after a failed pitch to rework *Starlight Express*. Their new project premiered at the Cambridge Theatre, produced by the Really Useful Group and Cameron Mackintosh. Josie Walker played Mary, David Shannon portrayed John, with Hannah Waddingham and Ben Goddard as Christine and Del. Meryl Tankard’s choreography fused football moves with dance, set against Michael Levine’s stark, black-box design. Despite a £3 million loss and a tourism slump post-9/11, its 11-month run and critical nods marked it as a bold, if polarizing, West End venture.

The Plot: Football and Fractured Lives

In 1969 Belfast, a Catholic football team coached by Father O’Donnell thrives amid rising tensions. John, a star striker, and Mary fall in love, while Del, a Protestant on the team, courts Christine. As The Troubles escalate, the team’s triumphs like winning a final give way to tragedy: Ginger’s murder, John’s imprisonment, and Thomas’s IRA ties. The second act tracks John’s radicalization and eventual redemption through marriage to Mary, ending with a hopeful, if subdued, nod to peace. Elton’s narrative, centered on football as “the beautiful game,” probes how violence shatters youth, love, and community, offering a raw counterpoint to musical theatre’s usual escapism.

Standout Performances and Staging

Josie Walker’s Mary anchored the show with fierce tenderness, her “Our Kind of Love” a standout ballad, earning a Best Actress Olivier nomination. David Shannon’s John evolved from naive athlete to conflicted prisoner with vocal grit, while Hannah Waddingham’s Christine and Ben Goddard’s Del brought doomed romance to life. Carsen’s direction, with Tankard’s athletic choreography, staged football matches and riots on a minimalist set, lit starkly by Jean Kalman. The ensemble including a young Dianne Pilkington drove the energy, though some critics felt the staging’s sermonizing tone overshadowed character depth, a tension that defined its West End reception.

Musical Score and Mixed Reception

Lloyd Webber’s score melds Irish folk with soaring ballads “Let Us Love in Peace,” “The Beautiful Game,” and “All the Love I Have” among them earning praise as his strongest since *Aspects of Love*. Elton’s lyrics, like the witty “A Little Priest” nod in “The Craic,” shone, but drew flak for clichéd rhymes and heavy-handedness. Critics split: *The Sunday Times* lauded its “energy and intelligence,” likening it to *West Side Story*, while *The Independent* panned the “uninspired” book. Audiences embraced the music Shonagh Daly sang “Let Us Love in Peace” at a 9/11 memorial yet its serious tone struggled against the era’s lighter musicals.

Legacy and Evolution

After closing, *The Beautiful Game* was reworked as *The Boys in the Photograph*, debuting in Canada in 2009 with a brighter ending and “Our Kind of Love” repurposed for *Love Never Dies*. A 2014 Union Theatre revival, directed by Lotte Wakeham, streamlined its intimacy, while the National Youth Music Theatre staged it at The Other Palace in 2018. Australian premieres followed in 2016 and 2019, and Northern Ireland saw rare amateur runs in 2012 and 2023. Its cast recording and licensing by Concord Theatricals keep it alive, a testament to its niche appeal despite never hitting Broadway.

Why The Beautiful Game Endures

The Beautiful Game persists for its unflinching look at youth caught in conflict, its football metaphor resonating beyond Belfast. Lloyd Webber’s evocative score and Elton’s compassionate, if flawed, script offer a rare musical take on political strife, appealing to those who crave theatre with bite. Its West End run, though not a blockbuster, showcased a daring shift from Lloyd Webber’s typical grandeur, and its cult status reflects a hunger for stories that marry melody with meaning. A flawed but fierce creation, it remains a haunting echo of a divided past, proving beauty can emerge from even the ugliest games.